Points of View is our blog dedicated to exploring the critical corporate communications issues of the day through insights and videos of Fortune 500 business and communications execs, industry insiders and our team.
Leave a Reply
Recent Posts
- Collaboration Drives Communities
- Oscar Suris on Keys to Success in Any Industry
- A Higher Purpose is PR’s World Series
- Moving Beyond Reputation– It’s Character That Really Counts
- Can Social Networks Drive Professional Development?
- The Quantified SWOT: Try It, You’ll Like It
- PulsePoint Group Appoints Don V. Cogman as Chairman
- Nine More Characteristics of the Engaged Enterprise
- Digital Media Pioneer Paul Walker Joins PulsePoint Group As Partner
- Seven Characteristics of the Engaged Enterprise
Video Posts
- Oscar Suris on Keys to Success in Any Industry
- Seven Characteristics of the Engaged Enterprise
- Overcoming barriers to the adoption of corporate social media Part 3: Buy-In
- Bill Margaritis on most the important trends in the PR profession
- Overcoming the Barriers to Adopting Corporate Social Media - Part 2: Preparation
- Richard Jones on communications in an economic crisis
- Overcoming the Barriers to Adopting Corporate Social Media - Part 1: Culture
- The Scope of Social Media
- Paul Argenti on the greatest resistance to company adoption of social media
- Ray Jordan on learning from a tough situation
Tags
- Commentary
- video
- Leadership
- Social Media
- Reputation
- Organizational Design
- Professional Development
- PR Education
- Crisis & Issues Management
- Internal Communcations
- Talent
- Engaged Enterprise
- Trendspotting
- Compensation
- Productivity
- Page Society
- Influence
- media
- Branding
- In the News
- Media Relations
- Statistics
- Feedback
- Add new tag
- Organization Design
- Resource Allocation
- Managing Agencies
- CEO Counsel
- Activism
- Agency Consolidation
- Financial Crisis
- Ethics
- Grassroots
- FedEx
- Advertising
- Online Communities
Archives
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008

Bonus babies: Communicating incentive and retention payments in a skeptical era
Bill Feldman
March 23rd, 2009
This past week, it seems as though everyone in America from the president on down has a strong opinion about those AIG, Merrill Lynch, and Fannie Mae bonuses. “Outrage” has become the word du jour.
The public’s furor over AIG and the others will subside. But enhanced scrutiny of executive compensation, by regulators and shareholders, may not – even for companies that aren’t imploding or finding the federal government as their biggest shareholder. Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke is urging companies to align executive incentives with corporate goals, and avoid “mismatches between the rewards and risks borne by institutions or their managers.” And Simon Johnson, a professor at MIT’s Sloan School of Management and former chief economist of the International Monetary Fund recently wrote that “offering guaranteed [retention] bonuses to virtually the entire operation is hardly the way to achieve the desired results. We should not let people think that the best way to guarantee job security is to lose lots of money in a really complicated way.”
Smart boards and CEOs, rather than hunkering down, will take a fresh look at their incentive and retention arrangements. Can they pass muster in a more skeptical environment? Do they really incentivize – or are they just a back-door way of paying people? And even if you’re satisfied that they’re appropriate, are you prepared to communicate them internally and externally, and defend them against attack?
This is hardly the first time questions have been raised about excessive compensation. In the merger wave of the 1980s, when managements were accused of entrenching themselves at the expense of shareholders, renewed emphasis on corporate governance led to strengthened independent directors, compensation committees, and attempts to link executive compensation with stock price.
The result: Increased use of stock options to align management’s interests more closely with shareholders. But they led to their own problems: stock price manipulation, back-dating, earnings management, and perhaps worst of all, decision-making that emphasized short-term stock price movements at the expense of long-term financial health.
Now the focus is on bonuses. The public is asking – rightly – what kind of “heads I win, tails you lose” formulas could require eight-figure payoffs to the senior executives of companies that not only performed poorly, but failed spectacularly? At the same time, the wider crisis in the financial sector virtually guarantees that all companies will experience renewed efforts at regulation, a more active SEC, and more skeptical shareholders for all companies, not just those currently embattled.
So, from a communications and reputational perspective, how should senior management be preparing?
Finally, if the worst happens, are you prepared with crisis management plan that incorporates social/digital media? Much of the outrage over AIG built on the blogosphere even before it exploded in Washington. Have you thought about what you will say, how you will target key audiences, and how much you will divulge about the compensation of individuals whose compensation does not otherwise need to be disclosed in SEC filings?
Of course, lawyers and HR people must be on the team answering these questions, but it’s clear from the events of the last few weeks that the communications and investor relations people need to be there, too. It’s also clear that smart companies will make a serious effort to answer these questions now.
Bill Feldman is a Senior Counselor with PulsePoint Group. His bio can be found here. He can be reached at wfeldman@pulsepointgroup.com
Tags: Commentary, Compensation, Social Media